Rahul Gandhi claimed the selection process was opaque and accused the government of reducing the appointment procedure to a “formality” while bypassing proper scrutiny of candidates.
BY PC Bureau
May 12, 2026: A political row erupted on Tuesday over the selection of the next Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) director, after Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi formally submitted a dissent note alleging lack of transparency in the appointment process and claiming that key evaluation documents were withheld from him.
Rahul Gandhi, who is part of the three-member committee responsible for appointing the CBI chief along with the Prime Minister and the Chief Justice of India, shared a screenshot of his dissent on X, escalating tensions over the selection procedure.
In his letter, the Congress MP accused the government of misusing central agencies such as the CBI to target political opponents, journalists, and critics. He argued that the presence of the Leader of Opposition on the panel was meant to safeguard against “institutional capture,” but said the process had instead been reduced to a formality.
“Despite repeated written requests, I was not provided with self-appraisal or 360-degree evaluation reports of the eligible candidates. Instead, I was expected to examine records of 69 candidates for the first time during the meeting itself. A proper review of these documents is essential to assess their performance and integrity,” he wrote, calling the exercise “a mockery of selection.”
I have written to the Prime Minister recording my dissent from the CBI Director selection process.
I cannot abdicate my constitutional duty by participating in a biased exercise.
The Leader of Opposition is not a rubber stamp. pic.twitter.com/WfSt5gGPPR
— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) May 12, 2026
READ: NEET-UG 2026 Leak: BAMS Student Arrested in Nashik
Rahul Gandhi further said he had raised similar objections in previous meetings but received no response. He maintained that participating in what he described as a biased process would amount to compromising his constitutional responsibility, stating that “the Leader of Opposition is not a rubber stamp.”
The meeting took place at Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s residence at 7 Lok Kalyan Marg and lasted over an hour. Current CBI Director Praveen Sood is scheduled to complete his tenure on May 24, with his successor expected to be named shortly.
Sources said several senior IPS officers are under consideration for the top post, including Parag Jain, Shatrujeet Kapoor, Yogesh Gupta, G.P. Singh, and Praveer Ranjan.
The development has once again reignited the long-standing political debate over autonomy and transparency in the functioning of investigative agencies in India. Opposition leaders have repeatedly alleged that central probe agencies are being used selectively, a charge the government has consistently denied.
Meanwhile, officials familiar with the process said the selection committee deliberated on the suitability of shortlisted officers based on service records, experience, and seniority. However, no official statement has been issued on Rahul Gandhi’s dissent note.
