• Power Corridors Magazines
  • Advertise with us
Tuesday, July 8, 2025
  • Login
Power Corridors
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
    • Technology
  • Appointments/Transfers
  • Automobile
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
    • IPL 2024
  • Event
  • World
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
    • Technology
  • Appointments/Transfers
  • Automobile
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
    • IPL 2024
  • Event
  • World
No Result
View All Result
Power Corridors
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Appointments/Transfers
  • Automobile
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Event
  • World
Home Blog

The Mate Case (Part-3): NIA Relies Solely on Manipur Police Claims

In the third part of our investigative series, we unpack how the NIA is opposing bail for Thangminlen Mate—citing UAPA provisions and relying solely on Manipur police testimonies.

Navin Upadhyay by Navin Upadhyay
6 July 2025
in Blog
70
Special Report | The Mate Case (Part 1): NIA Goof-Up, Bail, and Rearrest
72
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

In this third installment of our five-part series examining the arrest and legal proceedings against Thangminlen Mate, we turn the spotlight on the prosecution’s arguments opposing bail—and its fraught reliance on police testimonies from a force previously declared “incapable of investigation” by India’s top court.

Navin Upadhyay

July 2025 — Thangminlen Mate, a Kuki-Zo tribal leader and resident of Moreh, was arrested by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) in May 2025 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) for his alleged role in a deadly January 17 attack on the IRB post at Ima Khondong Lairembi in Moreh. The incident left one rifleman dead and two others injured. The NIA contends that Mate is not only complicit but a key figure in an extremist conspiracy. His bail plea—Petition No. 510/2025—was fiercely contested by the agency.

But there’s a catch: the prosecution’s case hinges almost entirely on statements from the Manipur Police Commandos. And this is the same Manipur Police that the Supreme Court, in August 2023, found unfit to investigate crimes amid the ethnic violence in the state. The court had slammed the force’s conduct, stating:

“The investigation is so lethargic, FIRs are registered after so long, arrests not made, statements not recorded… There is a complete breakdown of law and order and constitutional machinery in the state.”

READ: SC Shows Rulebook to Ex-CJI Chandrachud, Asks Govt to Reclaim Bungalow

Despite this judicial rebuke, the NIA appears to be leaning heavily on Manipur Police accounts, offering little corroborative evidence to support its charges against Mate.

The NIA’s Case: Procedural Rigor, Legal Hurdles

During the bail hearing before the Guwahati Special NIA Judge, Public Prosecutor D. Bharadwaj strongly opposed any relief for Mate, calling him an “influential person” involved in “heinous” offenses and citing strict UAPA provisions that make bail difficult by design. He claimed that Mate’s continued detention is necessary to safeguard public safety and prevent him from interfering with the investigation.

According to Bharadwaj, ten Manipur Police Commando personnel had given statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C., directly implicating Mate and other alleged Kuki militants in the Moreh attack. Mate was arrested on May 19 after what the NIA called “due identification.” He was presented before the Special Court the following day and remanded to police custody for eight days. The prosecution claimed “incriminating materials” were recovered that not only link Mate to the January attack but also implicate others.

Bharadwaj further stated that Mate had been informed of the grounds for arrest, that his father was notified, and that all procedures were followed in compliance with Article 22(1) and Article 21 of the Constitution. In other words, the arrest, he argued, was neither illegal nor arbitrary.

The UAPA Roadblock: Law Tilted Against Bail

The prosecution also leaned heavily on legal precedent to bolster its argument. Citing the Supreme Court’s 2024 ruling in Gurwinder Singh vs State of Punjab, Bharadwaj reminded the court that the bar for bail under UAPA is exceptionally high. The judgment underscored that in such cases, the idea of “bail as the rule” and “jail as the exception” does not apply. Rather, the Act enshrines the opposite logic.

The Mate Case (Part-2): Defense Strategy – Picking Apart the NIA Case, Line by Line#ThangminlenMate #LeninMate #NIACase #MorehAmbush #ManipurConflict #UAPA #AdvocateAlongbarBasumatary https://t.co/6iPWThk6dQ

— POWER CORRIDORS (@power_corridors) July 5, 2025

Section 43D(5) of the UAPA states that bail shall not be granted if there are “reasonable grounds for believing the accusations are prima facie true.” The standard of proof required at this stage is deliberately low, and even a tenuous link, if unchallenged, is sufficient to keep an accused incarcerated.

The prosecution emphasized that this statutory threshold had been met and that Mate’s release would risk witness intimidation and derail the investigation. The “tripod test”—flight risk, potential to tamper with evidence, and likelihood of influencing witnesses—need not even be considered unless the prima facie case collapses, Bharadwaj argued.

A Tenuous Case?

Yet, despite the legal framework and the forcefulness of the NIA’s argument, observers have pointed out the lack of substantial corroboration beyond Manipur Police accounts—an institution that, to reiterate, has been discredited by the Supreme Court for its poor performance during the Manipur conflict.

Want to know the real story behind the arms haul READ This: No Arrests. Behind Manipur’s Arms Haul, a Quiet Deal?

Civil liberties groups and legal experts watching the case note that the NIA has not presented physical evidence, digital records, or eyewitness testimonies beyond the controversial commando statements. That absence may not violate UAPA’s legal thresholds, but it raises broader questions about the fairness and credibility of prosecuting individuals under India’s most stringent anti-terror law.

Mate’s supporters claim he is being targeted for his political activism. His arrest on May 19, 2025, came weeks after he filed a complaint alleging police atrocities and unlawful detention of civilians in Moreh.

Tags: Manipur policeNIAThangminlen Mate
Plugin Install : Subscribe Push Notification need OneSignal plugin to be installed.
Previous Post

Tibetan Parliament Pays Tribute to Dalai Lama on 90th Birthday

Next Post

CBI Begins Probe into Sandeshkhali Violence; Registers FIR against Shahjahan Sheikh

Related Posts

Analysis! Are We Doing Enough to Combat the Rise in Cancer Cases?
Blog

Analysis! Are We Doing Enough to Combat the Rise in Cancer Cases?

7 July 2025
Chirag Paswan’s ‘243 Seats’ Gambit: Will He Walk the Talk?
Blog

Chirag Paswan’s ‘243 Seats’ Gambit: Will He Walk the Talk?

7 July 2025
Myanmar refugees
Blog

Thousands of Myanmar Refugees Flee to Mizoram Amid Chin Rebel Clashes

7 July 2025
Land, Autonomy, and Protest: Assam’s Tribals Hold the Key to 2026 Polls
Blog

Land, Autonomy, and Protest: Assam’s Tribals Hold the Key to 2026 Polls

7 July 2025
The Mate Case (Part-4): Why a Dreaded Militant Walks Free Despite More Evidence
Blog

The Mate Case (Part-4): Why a Dreaded Militant Walks Free Despite More Evidence

7 July 2025
Honoring a Life of Light: Celebrations Across Continents for Dalai Lama at 90
Blog

Opinion: India Can’t Stay Neutral on Dalai Lama’s Succession

7 July 2025
Next Post
CBI Begins Probe into Sandeshkhali Violence; Registers FIR against Shahjahan Sheikh

CBI Begins Probe into Sandeshkhali Violence; Registers FIR against Shahjahan Sheikh

Will Gill Lead India to History at Edgbaston, Or Will Rain Play Spoilsport?

Will Gill Lead India to History at Edgbaston, Or Will Rain Play Spoilsport?

‘Dhurandhar’ Teaser: Ranveer Singh’s Fierce Avatar Goes Viral, Sunny Deol Homage Sparks Smiles

‘Dhurandhar’ Teaser: Ranveer Singh’s Fierce Avatar Goes Viral, Sunny Deol Homage Sparks Smiles

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POWER CORRIDORS

Former Vice President Venkaiah Naidu commended Power Corridors as a commendable news magazine, affirming that it not only upholds Media Dharma but also fulfills its societal obligations. Power Corridors, as its name implies, delves into realpolitik—examining the essence of influential circles, unraveling the intricacies of political maneuvers, and exploring the pulse of the state’s affairs. However, it transcends mere power dynamics, encompassing a broader spectrum of issues beyond the confines of Delhi’s elite circles.

For PC, which is published by the Interactive Forum on Indian Economy, not only highlights the issues of the day but also throws up what ought to be the subjects that the country should be debating about. It reports about the plans, strategies, and agendas of politicians and others; it also sets the agenda for the nation.

Browse by Category

  • Appointments/Transfers
  • Automobile
  • Aviation
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Event
  • GMF
  • HEALTH
  • IFIE
  • IPL 2024
  • Law
  • Motorsports
  • National
  • News
  • Politics
  • Science
  • Space
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Weather
  • WEIGHT LOSS
  • World

Recent News

Analysis! Are We Doing Enough to Combat the Rise in Cancer Cases?

Analysis! Are We Doing Enough to Combat the Rise in Cancer Cases?

7 July 2025
Bihar Horror: Five Tribals Burnt Alive Over Witchcraft Suspicion

Bihar Horror: Five Tribals Burnt Alive Over Witchcraft Suspicion

7 July 2025
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact Us

© 2023 Power Corridors

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
  • Login
  • News
  • National
  • Politics
  • Business
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Crime
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Contact Us

© 2023 Power Corridors